Despite the importance of Halloween to the witching community, a night in was all Hazel really wanted, forgoing spending time outside for reading her book while watching the children trick or treating from the bowl on her porch. However, as the night grows long, one young adult decides to steal more than his fair share, thinking the house to be abandoned. Unbeknownst to him, he was being watched, and Hazel was not about to let him get away with whatever he wanted.

Reports of blaring music, obnoxious partygoers and even fireworks bombarded the park office throughout the night, and Sally, the frustrated ranger, trudges out to investigate, however, when she arrives at the spot that the reports led to, she finds the campsite completely trashed and abandoned. Unbeknownst to her as she begin to clean up, the campers weren't as far gone as she thought.