Reviewer: pkong Signed
Date: March 17 2014
Title: Chapter 2: Explanation
Holy fast Chapter update! I didn't expect anouther chapter for a week! Awesome!
Anyway, I'm going to echo a lot of other reviwers when I say, I hope this ruins the relationship between these girls for all time. I mean I get what Ashley did wrong. I imagine what Claire was giong to say was the difference was consent, which is important. But, i think Jenna is making several mistakes here.
1. It is not the place of the big sister and her friends to decide on a punishment for a little sister, no matter what she did. jenna should have left this to their parents.
2. It sounds like Ashley is a good girl who made an innocent mistake, not like the girls from consequences who knew what they did was wrong. Jenna barely even gave her a chance to defend herself and then didn't even tell her why she was being punished. Isn't that punishment 101, telling the accused what their accused of?
3. The omegas seem to be way overreacting. this problem probably could have been resolved with a stern talking too and maybe a grounding. instead they apply a procedure designed for criminals? And before you defend that this is what would have happened in two years, theres a reason kids arn't charged as adults. Because as in this case, sometimes they really don't understand what they are doing is wrong. the law itself deemed this type of punishment inappropriate for ashley, who are they to decide that it is?
4. Finally, it sounds like this is partly Claires fault. Clearly Ashley was copying her to get a boy she might have been crushing on. Someone should have spoken to her about consent before, now their blaming her for not knowing?
These are just a few reasons Ashley would be well within her rights to hate her sister and her friends for all time (especially Jenna who looks way too into this fore someone whoose supposed to be the girls friend). I hope you have an epilougue in this story so we can see what happened to their relasionship afterwords. And unless the Omega girls can muster some pretty convincing arguments, I would be dissapointed to find out Ashley forgave them for this.
P.S I just realized that we don't know alot about the laws the Omegas set down. I mean it didn't matter in the other story because almost beating a man to death is obviously a crime anywhere. But what law did Ashley break exactly? Is this assault?
Author's Response: This is kind of another case where I won't neccessarily disagree as the author. The characters themselves obviously feel differently, but that also doesn't really sway shit either way. When it comes down to it we're talking about three 18 year old girls that are still in school themselves and aren't quite done growing up yet in a situation where emotions are running high, and it's easily possible that they made a bad decision in going through with this, or that they could have accomplished the same thing without resorting to the current plan. They can make good decisions and they can make bad ones, even when it comes to impressing upon Ashley the constructive lessons they feel she needs to learn.
Though I will say that #4 is being a bit personally unfair to Claire. She did note that she isn't the one that let her personal activities slip, and that she wasn't keen on them being known.