Reviewer: carnaj2 Signed
Date: November 09 2013
Title: Tales of a Shrinking Sister
I do like your story and am enjoying reading about Kate's continuous abuse at the hands of her sisters in their efforts to get her to shrink down to a more manageable size. You do ask for opinions and suggestions however, so...
First, you are a good writer, and getting better the more you post. I know we all, when writing, want to finish the story and get it online, but do try to take an extra moment and give your story another read through before posting. Your grammer is good but I've noted minor mistakes in spelling which detract from the reading enough to be annoying at times. Don't rely wholly on your 'spell check' as it is far from perfect. A final thorough read through will catch the little things and you will feel better about your work in the end as will the reader.
Second, DO try to double space between the paragraphs. As a reader (whose eyesight is not what it used to be), nothing turns me away more than seeing one huge block of text to read, especially in a story that I know is otherwise going to be good, like yours. Technical stuff I know, but in the end it's generally the little things that improve the quality of your writing.
As far as the story itself, I enjoyed the two chapters that developed Jessica's background and character. I think they were probably the two best chapters you've written thus far, despite there being no 'shrinking'. Jessica is probably now the most believable character of those that you have developed and I hope that she can continue to resist Stacy, Amy and whoever else when they turn their attentions on her to try to make her shrink.
You've developed Amy as a believable character as well, showing her as the little sister that really hasn't matured enough to understand that what she is doing is wrong and wanting to make her older sister, Stacy, like her and be proud of her. That's a natural stage for a little kid, to look up to and want to be like an older sibling, and with only Stacy seeming in that role it works. Hoping however that Amy will at some point feel some pity for Kate and eventually back off some. I think that will take some serious injury to Kate however, which seems on the horizon since Stacy is becoming crueler with each chapter.
Stacy as the middle sister is believable to a point. Wanting attention and going through puberty, now suddenly in a position of power over Kate who was once an authority figure to her all makes sense. She is high on the power she now has over Kate and getting revenge on her older sister for all the times she feels that Kate 'abused' or sleighted her as older siblings unthinkingly do. How extreme Stacy will go with her revenge is the question however. In the beginning if I recall correctly you painted the picture of a loving family, though perhaps not incredibly close as the mother has to work so much and relies on the older daughters to hold things together. It makes me wonder if that adds to Stacy's cruel side - the lack of the mother's involvement? Possibly, but I'm not a psychiatrist. Stacy definitely has issues though, which i hope will eventually be dealt with.
The least believable aspect of the story is the mother's apparent lack of concern over what is happening with Kate. You've made it clear that she is a busy woman, working most of the time, but she seems to have no love at all for Kate or her condition. You showed her actually totally ignoring Kate at one point - going to school scene if I recall correctly. I wonder if maybe Kate is a result of an extra-marrital affair, or even a rape, making the mother resent her or think less of her eldest daughter? Hopefully you'll shed some light on that in an upcoming chapter.
As far as Emma is concerned, i would hate to see her suddenly become an antagonist. She has so far been the one holding the family together, and while she seems oblivious as to what the other two sisters have been doing to Kate, she at least shows some concern over her older sister's plight. Having her do a sudden about face and join in on the torturing would seem to me to be out of character at this point. Plus, walking in on the scene in the bedroom with Kate naked, hurt and crying on the floor should finally throw up some red flags of warning that things have been happening behind her back. I have no doubt that Stacy will be able to lie her way out of the situation, but the seed of doubt should be planted.
I'm not saying that Emma won't or shouldn't become one of Kate's tormentors, but as she seems to be the head of the household now, her involvement should not be as extreme or direct as that of Stacy and Amy. You've written her with a sense of maturity given her new role in the family and you should stick with that I think. However there are ways that she as the 'Mother Figure' can unwittingly add to Kate's humiliation and shrinking without becoming an outright tormentor.
Not necessarily a 'better' suggestion, but a suggestion none the less: Emma steps into the bedroom and finds Kate on the floor hurt, crying, naked and shrunk to less than half the size she was since the night before. Not being stupid, Emma puts two and two together and realizes what Stacy and Amy have been doing to Kate and puts a stop to it (or so she believes). She reprimands Stacy and Amy (though not necessarily beating the shit out of them) and tries to keep Kate more under her own supervision. Running the household and taking care of the youngest sister (whose name escapes me at the moment) is a lot for her however, as she is still young herself. Now having Kate underfoot all the time simply adds to her burden and, exasperated, she takes out her frustrations on her older sister, finding fault in anything Kate does, annoyed that she has to do everything for Kate who can no longer fend for herself. Verbal abuse woulkd naturally develope followed by things like corner time, spankings, etc., all of which woulkd add to Kate's humiliation and thus continued shrinking. Stacy, being the seemingly smartest one in the family, would catch on to this and she would find ways to make Kate 'mess up' in Emma's eyes, with Amy of course following Stacy's lead.
Kate at this point should realize that she has no hope outside of Emma. Stacy's threats about her keeping quiet should no longer matter and she should realize that whether she does or doesn't say something about the abuse she is going to shrink regardless. Kate should speak up now and try to get Emma's help to at least stave off her fate a bit. If Emma believes Kate, that does not mean that Stacy and Amy will not continue to abuse her, but they just have to get more creative and sneaky when they do so. And of course the torment only becomes worse because Kate ratted them out.
Anyway, and since my review and comments have rambled on longer than your story chapter I will close by reiterating that I am truly enjoying your tale and look forward to each new installment. Any suggestions are simply that; suggestions in my opinion. In the end, though we all write hoping that others will like our work, we first write for ourselves. Always keep that in mind and be happy that you are doing a good job.
Keep up the great work and looking forward to more...
Author's Response: 1) so better spelling? i can put a bit more effort into it. it is probably my weakest point but i am not one for rereading my own work to find mistakes but i can try from now on.
2)double space paragraphs? tbh i actually didn't think would have a problem with the spacing but if it is an issue i can totally change it. leaving a space would actually be easier because i would only have to press enter rather than enter+shift.
3)i'm glad that people enjoyed those chapters even though there was no shrinking. I thought i was kind of pushing it putting in two chapters with no shrink action so i tried to balance it by putting in a few scenes where Jessica beats the crap out of people.
4) i'm glad that you find Amy believable i wanted her to be the kind of innocent torturer. Don't worry she'll change her ways, she'll still want to keep Kate as a foot pet but she will rebel against Stacy
5) other people have commented that the mother seems out of character and i understand. from the start i said that she works too much and that is why she doesn't see the kids but this was when i was just starting out and had no idea where the story was going. the mother will be introduced soon as a full character i just need to figure out whaat she'll be like. i don't think she'll be mean but she could be stern or angry that her eldest daughter is shrinking.
6) your suggestion for emma is brillant and i will probably use it. this will allow me to keep her as a good character but also a semi torturer. thank you so much for that suggestion =) and i hope you continue to enjoy the read.