Reviewer: TheZiku6000 Signed
Date: March 14 2021
Title: Chapter 9: Chapter 9, Week 5: After School
Hello again! :)
I think it's fair to say that this is another good chapter with some lighter stuff before dropping a big bomb which I hope that won't prove fatal to any of the boys. The game was desribed quite well and I really enjoyed it (although sometimes I REALLY want to slap myself on the forehead for having a hard time at figuring out that these girls were actually playing volleyball xD).
Moving on to your question from response to my last review: No, I'm not a lawyer or law student. I just happened to play a visual novel series called "Ace Attorney". These games are about solving murder mysteries while defending people were wrongly accused of commiting a murder. Our goal is to collect evidence and useful informations from people involved in the case during the investigation segment, and then use them appropriately in the trial segment to expose lies or mistakes in witnesses' testimonies. This will lead us to proving our client's innocence and help us find the true culprit. As you might expect, there are many law terms in these games introduced in a way it is easy to understand and they later just sort of stay in your head. Some court shows from TV were a bit helpful, too. The first three games even have an anime adaptation, which was the beginning of my interest in anime, manga, light novels and visual novels, so you may call me an "otaku" if you want to. :)
And even if you're not interested in this kind of stuff, I really recommend this series. :)
When a trial was mentioned and I got a feeling that penalty was way too severe, I remembered a motive from the sixth game, which was about a country with the law stating that of defendant is found guilty, their sentence goes double for the defence and the aftermath was that there were hardly any lawyers there. I know this probably doesn't have very much in common with your concept, but I figured if people were willing to shrink criminals, then in some countries it would be no surprise to go even farther. Also, if judges aren't complaining about their situation, then the only possibility that comes to my mind is that they have less work (because, as you mentioned before, trials became rarer), but earn the same or maybe even higher amount of money as before.
I think it's fair to say that policy of dealing with criminals changed from resocialization to disposal. It feels like the first person to put this idea to use may have had very similar sense of justice to the protagonist of "Death Note". I know this question most likely calls for another story to be answered, but I wonder who was our "Kira" in this situation.
Moving on to the next topic, I wonder whether Ms Johnson can actually be moved by something, if she watched and/or read any kind of tearjackers. If she can, then I would imagine her as a kind of person who's moved, but when it happens, she doesn't cry and it's hard to tell just from expression on her face.
I also want to include my thoghts about what would I do if I were in this kind of reality.
First, I would be very afraid of dating any girl (for the record: I only have interest in the opposite sex), because of possibility that she might be enjoying trearing shrunken people as playthings and not have any regard for their lives. Even if I actually DID fall in love, I would just wait it out until this feeling will have disappered.
Second, I would start collecting money in order to move to the country where policy of shrinking convicts isn't put to use and is not going to be anytime soon.
I also think it's not exagaration to call this kind of reality a dystopia (I have a feeling that I'm repeating myself from the last review here, but even if that's the case, why the hell not? xD).
Last but not least, this universe gives so mamy possibilities, that you pretty much never can run out of ideas with it, so keep up the good job. :)
Greetings from middle-eastern Europe!
Have a nice week! :)
Author's Response: You all need to pay attention to the chapters that come before the new ones hahaha. But yeah, I've heard a few times that I should've been clearer about what they were playing. I figured that between the tight black short shorts, the number of players, and the net between the two sides it would've been enough lol. Anyways, I'll tweak that before I release the next chapter. The next chapter is gonna drop a few big bombs for sure. I'm really hoping that I can do this next chapter justice. I can not confirm or deny whether or not someone will die though. You're gonna have to wait and tune in!
Sounds like a cool game! I figured in just the way you word things and what you seem most interested in you're someone who might be working in the law and ethics field (hence why I guessed lawyer or law student!). I've heard so many people talk about Death Note and now you're another. I'm really gonna have to check that out.
I love that one comment you made and it's had me really thinking over the last few weeks. I've been trying to think of how I wanted to reply to that. I think you're definitely right, even though I wasn't originally intending on the world being a dystopia (to be honest I'm not even sure what I was originally intending in terms of world type), that seems to be exactly where it's heading (or has already become). And that's really had my mind working as I've been thinking of new ideas and tweaking others. It raises an interesting question of, well who is the dystopia for? Cause I don't picture the government having an iron grip on society and everyone fearing to step outside their doors. It's almost a mini-dystopia for men since they're now being punished for their actions (women too, but to a lesser extent). But at the same time I'm picturing it being more of a "hawk waiting on the branch" type world where the hawk is waiting for just the right animal to pick off even though there could be a thousand pass by. People can still do bad things to one another without being shrunken and handed off to be disposed of, but every once and a while someone will do something bad enough to justify someone stepping in and putting a complete stop to it. Cause we've heard Ms. Johnson explain a little bit about the world to the disposables and she makes the point of "the government is willing to consider even the smallest of crimes." But the interesting part about that line is we're listening to her from Troy's perspective and not seeing inside Ms. Johnson's mind. Cause besides Troy, so far we've only met really bad people who were turned into disposables. So it begs the questions again, what justifies being turned into a disposable and why was Troy shrunk? Is Ms. Johnson being serious when she says that even the pettiest of crimes will justify shrinking, or could it be something else? Sometimes it's well deserved. Sometimes examples need to be made. Sometimes there's a little more beneath the surface.
And yes, I'm definitely seeing criminals being more "disposed of" than "resocialized". Which comes back to the motive of at first they were shrunken and given a second chance, but then they saw just how badly the rich and famous wanted the tiny people. So who gets a second chance now? The origin of this world would definitely be a complex one and I'm not even sure if I have the answer to it haha. I definitely have a lot of rough ideas and a blurry picture, but I'm not even sure if I would be capable of writing a convincing origin of "this is how shrinking criminals started and grew into what it is now." There would be sooo much to unpack. We're sort of seeing shards of that origin story inside this one though.
I also love your other question about Ms. Johnson. This is absolutely something I've thought of for a long time (even before I started writing chapter 1 and was just starting to outline the characters and the story). The end of Chapter 1 (before we see her in present day) was a pivotal moment in her life but it was like the tv was shut off just before we got to fully see what Ms. Johnson's reaction was to the death of Todd. We only got to see a split second glimpse. That was the first (and perhaps only time) Ms. Johnson has ever actually lost someone she cared for. Since then they've just been meaningless disposables and test subjects. This question does not require another story to answer (lol) and you will get an answer to this in a future chapter. Lets just say that Noah (or maybe Alexis) is going to be speaking with someone who knows a lot more about Ms. Johnson than he and Alexis do.
Girls are fun though! And they just wanna have fun :) I can totally see why you would be feeling this way and you won't be the only one to be feeling this way for long. I've purposefully started the story off by introducing disposables first before we get into any major personal stuff though. We'll see if you can be convinced otherwise before the story is finished hehe. Who knows, it might be a back and forth pulling though and maybe that's what the author will be going for :)
I totally agree with the number of possibilities this world has to offer though! I know you said that you had an idea that you wanted to share with my privately and you still can. I'd love to hear it! Not sure if you saw, but in one of my other chapters I posted some contact methods. This review section works for me too though! Instagram: LittleLearningGTS, Discord: AprilMJ#7988, Email: LittleLearningGTS@gmail.com.
Thanks for your interest and support! Nighty night from Canada :)