Reviewer: SizePrincess Signed
Date: January 25 2024
Title: Chapter 23: Saturday
So, you're what? Deleting reviews that are critical of the ending instead of leaving them up for others to see. (as I saw a critical review the other day which has now strangely, magically dissapeared, hm, wonder how that happened?)
I for one agree with the (now deleted, if anyone else sees this be warned your reviews may not last) review about the ending being a letdown. (but this was similar for 'with great power')
you set up Natalie as a caring, albeit somewhat distracted with her work, parent.
And throughout the story have Jules going through great lengths to keep the fact she's torturing her nephew (and sexually abusing him/raping him at one point) from her sister, and even here where she's worried about her sisters reaction as Natalie *seems* pissed off.
Only for Natalie to bend and shift around to Jules ideals......even when Tim is desperately telling her what has been happening, and Natalie has now seen/heard first hand some of the stuff she's done?
What would it take for Tim to be missing an arm for Natalie to say "Enough's enough, you're abusing my son for kicks." ?
The ending here was a let down for anyone who's read the story and were expecting a satisfying conclusion and some catharsis for Tim after suffering so much.
I know size based stories can often have bad endings, but the characterization has to fit, and here you just changed Natalie around at the last minute, purely to just screw with Tim.
Which fine, if you'd set Natalie up as someone who would be fine with her son being raped and tortured by her sister, fair enough. But that wasn't the case here, you forced her into the part of conspirator now with her sister purely to fuck with the character of Tim, when the narrative you yourself had established flies in the face of that.
Author's Response: For starters, I would direct you to red356’s recently reposted review as to exactly what happened, as he’s a much more reliable source than I. I had actually already copied his reviews so I could write a more detailed response before he deleted them, but he kinda beat me to the punch.
Secondly, I’m not the type of author who purposefully deletes reviews just because someone has something negative to say, all I ask is that they’re polite about it. The only times I delete review is because 1) It was duplicated (which occasionally happens), so I delete the duplicate; 2) There was blatant harassment (which I have never experienced on this site); 3) The chapter to which the review was tied was deleted (which I have only done a couple of times because certain chapters had formatting issues that I couldn’t fix by just copying and pasting over); or 4) The reviewer deletes their own review (which is what happened in this case)
I always appreciate honest feedback — positive and negative — and I agree that all of your complaints are well warranted with regards to plot and character development, but if you recall, I stated from the get go and in the series’ descriptor that this story was going to be focusing primarily on the scenarios rather than plot and character development. Still, I would like those things to stand on their own.
Believe it or not, this is the ending I had in mind the entire from the beginning, and I wasn’t even considering the possibility of a sequel. I think that by the end, story ended up taking a few turns even with an outline in place that I didn’t set it up well. While this wasn’t my first foray into the “domineering giantess” genre, it IS the first time I had a character go through a shift from sweet and caring to somewhat dominant. I gotta say that this chapter took a lot of writing, editing, and rewriting — I find dialogue driven chapters usually are — but honestly, I also felt during that time that this ending was going to be hard to justify. In the end, I had Natalie snapping from all the stress and Tim whining, but I know now that I definitely needed a better setup for even this character shift to be believable. Perhaps I should’ve made Tim misbehave and act out more, or hinted more at Natalie getting stressed and anxious from all the pressure…unlike with the issues you raised with my story “With Great Power…” forcing me to rethink the ending, I actually want to keep this ending in place and maybe make adjustments to the story later down the road to help it make sense. I think I will also move forward with an epilogue to help set up a potential sequel, but I want to work on other projects for a bit before I really work on that.
Ultimately, let me just say that I do appreciate your candor and letting me know of your complaints. I’ll try to make adjustments moving forward.