You must login (register) to review.
Reviewer: TerryLarka Signed starstarstarstarstar [Report This]
Date: October 25 2023 10:43 PM Title: Balm in Gilead

An awesome mash-up of a popular movie/game genre and size smut, beautifully realized, and gushing with love and homages to zombie fiction of all types. Excellent work here!

As usual, your characters were really charming, especially Barb, the geeky shut-in turned badass zombie-slayer determined to protect her tiny lover. The bleak, apocalyptic setting contrasted nicely with all the heartwarming (and sexy) moments throughout the story. Cassie and Pete were great additions too, offering a slightly different flavor of the size dynamic seen with Barb and John. And Celia made for a fantastic villain, perfectly bratty and despicable while remaining tantalizing in an almost cruel giantess sort of way.

I found it interesting that the tinies are normal sized people with bigs being actual giants considering the entire story took place in an area where everything is scaled to the giant's size, so it's almost like they aren't giant at all. Nothing wrong with that, it just stood out to me as an interesting design choice.

The story was absolutely entertaining throughout, and I really liked the happy ending with Barb finally finding her place in the world and the friends she gathered along the way, and all that other gushy goodness.   



Author's Response:

October is certainly the best time of year to read this story, isn't it? Anyways I guess that the giants and tinies are both using the respective labels relative to one another, without the tinies the giants wouldn't call themselves that and vice versa.

The overall tone of this story is very much in line with the Romero movies, it's bleak and hopeless, yet it's pretty silly and upbeat at the same time. I'm obviously a fan of lighter endings than he was though. Thanks for reading!

Reviewer: Divediveburners Signed starstarstarstar [Report This]
Date: June 02 2023 6:09 PM Title: Balm in Gilead

You can't win "It Was Me"! I will be the longest Greenanon reviewer by the end of this day. I'll even make Longman Mauler himself tremble at my impressive length/ So much so, that he'll go back to Rakata prime to feast upon his green milk in shame that he's been outlonged!

Oh right, this is supposed to be a review, not a declaration of war. I have to say, I'm probably a good test for the objective enjoyment of this story, as every single zombie movie reference went over my head. It's never been a genre that has summoned my behind to a theater seat. 

Barbra possesses that same enthusiastic nerdy spunk that Kacey has in We Help Each Other Get By. The NEET nerd girl is a very fun character trope, and one that you've mastered. Her goal to become a cringe, katana-wielding zombie slayer was certainly one that kept me invested.

Sorry to say, however, that I didn't find John as interesting as Jake. While his devotion to Barb is admirable, and he possesses technical know-how to resolve the final conflict, I did find him to be a bit bland. I never really could impart defining characteristics he possessed on his own, while I can with Jake. Exacerbating this is that Peter, the initial captive of our villain, then later, Cassie's man, is almost identical in characterization. The fact that both end up as Celia's personal slaves at one point, does not help. To say the least, I had trouble differentiating them.

Speaking of Celia, she's the driver of most of the interest in this story, in that you are interested in seeing how she'll get her just desserts. Underlying a pragmatic need for hierarchy and order, is a neurotic need for dominance and control. I believe Barb's presence brought out her worst (despite her sacrificing the coach before, so it was always there), but a predator like her required a chew toy. This, of course, pushed Barb's development nicely, and allowed her victory over Celia to be all the sweeter.

The second hook for intrigue was the nebulous Rhames, and his need to be on the winning side. Showing no fear, and knowing when to fold, unlike Ceila, he's a nice, morally ambiguous contrast to the sadistic Celia, the soft Cassie, and the heroically ambitious Barb. 

Have to admit, I rather liked the smut scenes with Cassie for the ... let's just call it color commentary. Aright, I'll see myself out.

Unfortunately, I neither possess the length, nor the stamina to match "It Was Me", so I'll end the review here. Another entertaining classic of yours. I do think it would have benefitted with a more distinct characterization for John and Peter. The villains are what drive this story and maintain interest, and I think ending on their defeat wraps this up perfectly. Of course, in that hotel, who knows how long they'll last?



Author's Response:

Thanks for the review! This one is definitely an out there genre mashup with the zombie angle, so it's definitely got a lot of elements that would only appeal to fans of the genre lol. Anyways glad it was able to pull interest anyways. As far as Peter/John goes I imagined Peter as a more bookish type with John as a more hands on blue collar type, though admittedly you're right they could both use more variation in the characterization.

Anyways yeah the nerdy NEET girl is a fun character archetype I've revisited several times now lol. Not sure she counts as a NEET since at the end of the world everyone's kind of jobless, but she did find a niche and a community at the end I guess.

I like to think that they do all right in the hotel, and probably find a way to live there sustainably until they link up with other survivors, though it might get rough at times. A lot of zombie movies end on a really bleak note, I wanted this one to be a little upbeat, especially after all the characters went through.

Reviewer: PrayForPEPE Signed starstarstarstarstar [Report This]
Date: June 02 2023 7:10 AM Title: Balm in Gilead

I made an account here, despite my aversion to leaving an online footprint on porn sites, just to say that I came in for a quick wank and ended up staying for the story and characters. I did not expect to feel so involved honestly, it's kinda crazy. I even giggled out of excitement at certain plot points. And the way you write is really good too, it all just flows so well, I am legit impressed. I mean you literally put character arcs and rising stakes in a gosh darn fetish story. It is without a doubt the best fanfic I ever read. Thank you for your continued work, and may all the characters keep on living in your mind.



Author's Response:

Thanks a bunch! I always try to put some character development and plot in my longer stories, so if you're into that you should check some of them out. Anyways I'm glad you got sucked into this one, I really enjoyed writing it and while I wasn't sure about it at first I think it came out pretty good. Until next time!

Reviewer: It Was Me Signed starstarstarstarstar [Report This]
Date: June 02 2023 4:35 AM Title: Balm in Gilead

Balm in Gilead, huh? That's a good follow-up to your rising out of hell metaphor at the end of the last chapter. It sounds like the group found exactly what they needed.

I have to admit, I'm a bit sad to see this one end. Then again, I'd rather it end now than outstay its welcome by 7 or 8 seasons, maybe relocate to Virginia for a change of pace.

I love that Rhames had his weapon with him, even when he was lounging around in the tiny side of the resort. That's a very him thing to do. Also, it's great to see that he's lightening up a bit and starting to embrace the group mentality. His arc wasn't the focus of the story, obviously, but that's a nice little satisfying end to it nonetheless.

The contrast between Cassie's leadership style and Celia's is demonstrated pretty well in just a few paragraphs here and there. I didn't think that Cassie would keep the whole cheer captain title going, but it's a good sign that she didn't give herself a title at all, "undisciplined" though it may be to do so. It sends out a very "we're all in this together, but one of us has to be the final decisionmaker" vibe to counter Celia's "Do what I say or I'll murder you in a parking garage" style of management. This will probably do well to tear down the wall separating the cheerleaders and mall workers and even the one separating the tinies from the giants in general, too.

Also, Cassie took the time to actually assess the skills and former professions of all the "new recruits," which is an improvement in leadership as well. Seriously, a surgeon working at Cinnabon?! It looks like Celia choked on her lack of leadership skills.

Backing up a bit, I do like the fact that a month wasn't enough time for the cheerleaders, survivors, and tinies to start singing kumbaya together. While it's likely that the worst offenders died with Celia, some of the surviving cheerleaders probably weren't too kind to the mall workers and tinies before everything went to hell. And even if they weren't mean to the other two groups, the actions of Celia and the other cheerleaders are still going to be projected onto them, including Cassie, who we know really doesn't deserve it. But that's the way things go.

But yeah, I like where things are left at the end of the story, still a bit tense between the sub-groups but slowly coming together with hope that one day they can stop thinking of themselves in those terms.

I can't blame Barb for being all over John the second time in this chapter, what with his unintentional Leon cosplay and all. Also, regarding the quicktime event thing, has John even played a Resident Evil game? At times, I got the vibe that he hadn't, but there was the debate about Leon going in alone to save the president's daughter in Resident Evil 4 earlier in the story, so I wasn't sure if John was ever much of a gamer.

It was also a nice touch at the end, having Barb and Cassie bond over anime. It was made clear early in the story that both liked anime, and they had that Rurouni Kenshin moment in the parking garage, but it was good to see them geek out a bit over a common interest that was set up early on.

As far as the story as a whole goes, I, for one, am glad you fought that doubt at writing this, as it turned out really well! I would also encourage you to jump on any other "weird" ideas that you come up with in the future. I've got nothing against the countless stories here that rehash the same themes and scenarios over and over again (in fact, some of those stories are my among my favorites. It really is all in the execution of an idea), but seeing a story with a unique premise and new ideas was a welcome change of pace!

And the optimistic tone of this story is much appreciated. I can certainly appreciate things with a darker tone and even an unhappy ending (the ending to the original Night of the Living Dead is heartbreaking but perfect), but I generally want good things for the heroes of any story I find myself deeply invested in. This story did a good job of delivering

I guess you using the Day of the Dead soundtrack as inspiration when writing this would explain why I visualized so many scenes from this story in that old 70s/early 80s zombie movie style. I mentioned that one scene with Celia sniping a zombie early on, but most of the action scenes in this story gave me that same vibe.

Overall, this story was pretty great! Yeah, you may never have thought your zombie story was going to be a giantess one as well when you were younger, but you blended the two "genres" (not sure giantess is a genre, but fuck it) together perfectly. And you wrapped the whole thing around a NEET to boot. Excellent work!



Author's Response:

Thanks for the kind words and the support throughout this story! I'm always sad to see a longer story end too, but at the same time I like the bottle of wine metaphor, you can pour some water in to stretch a good bottle of wine, but with every bit you add you're diluting out what you like, we wouldn't want to Walking Dead ourselves lol, that's a bathtub full of water at this point. Yeah our main groups have a lot more "team building" they'll need before they're a fully cohesive group of survivors, but the implication at the end is that Cassie will be able to pull it off.

So John I imagine probably has some cursory familiarity with Resident Evil and might have played the more popular entries, 4 in particular, but wouldn't have a lot of in depth knowledge of the series. Barb on the other hand is a NEET obsessed with them so she's probably played all of them, the remakes, the remasters, the terrible spin offs lol, you might say that's how she knew what to do when the apocalypse hit, even if her plan was mostly to sit tight in her apartment and eat chips.

Overall this is a story of optimism even with all the grim horror, I figured that everyone deserved a bit of happiness after the nightmare they went through. Rhames, for all that he was an asshole who collaborated with Celia, was ultimately driven by his desire not to die in a mall, which if you think about it was one of the more sane motivations in the story. Barb, Cassie, John, and Peter all suffered in their own ways, at the same time they all passed their various "tests" and hence the arrival at the Gilead, a seven story hotel, the metaphor is thick on that one. As they say in Day of the Dead, and to John last chapter, "we're counting on you to fly us to the promised land!"

Anyways thanks again for all the long detailed reviews, if you like plot heavy giantess stories most of my longer ones have something going on lol, I'd love to hear your thoughts on Amazon Country or Abduction if you ever find yourself wanting to read them. Take care, we'll all meet again in Fiddler's Green!

You must login (register) to review.