Reviewer: Stubbornstain Signed
Date: November 04 2011
Title: Chapter 1: That Shrinking Feeling
Hi Veronica, welcome to giantessworld!
Wow, lots of new authors lately, this is awesome!
So I've been reason your story and spelling and grammar is pretty good although some bits were confusing. Like here:
"but she didn’t, her smile was that of concern." A smile is a happy emotion so I'm not sure smiles can show concern. I think you mean (facial) expression or look. Smile is the wrong word to use here me thinks.
Also, if Diana is Tim’s girlfriend why would she suddenly stop caring about Tim. I honestly thought that was a little odd and if turns out she doesn't like him then perhaps there should have been more of a build up to him being eaten. And it seems rather out of character of her to randomly put him in a sandwhich if she is his friend.
Here: "Tim understood and started to sulk off."
If Tim understood he wouldn't really sulk. He would maybe try to make conversation with Lilly whilst she prepares the food.
The end was really sudden and rather weird, I'm sorry. Not sure how he can instantly assume all these events are because of a trip to the mall two days ago. It almost felt like it was an afterthought thrown in at the end to quickly try and explain everything.
I hope my comments weren’t too harsh but I know you have lots of potential as a writer, and more you write and more stories your read the better you will become. I hope my comments were useful but if not then that's ok too. I wouldn’t want to discourage you from writing.
Author's Response: No. not at all. if anything it helps. Thanks so much. This was my first story and now I know how to improve. I appreciate it. Thanks