Reviewer: hadumba Signed
Date: January 04 2019
Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1: The Cat and the Mouse
Hi, just saw your new update and wanted to drop by and say some stuff.
Most of my favorite writers are gone and now we are stuck with you, which, still a good thing that you upload some decent quality stories. As I search some believability in strories and this perticular fetish is making most of the stories such a challenge. Hence there are such a small group of people writing what I enjoy about a story with believability, even if it's such an imposible fetish to exist in real world, consistency of the rules you build your world around, relatability of the characters even if they dont have human standards and of course good word forging helps alot. Don't downgrade your writing with simplified versions of your sentences, I'm not saying this because of this story but another author started his new story with his standard quality sentences and some person said its too confusing to read who is talking so place the name of the character speaking infront of the paragraph, now I have hard time reading it not because its too confusing but story simply feels ugly.
Sorry for the rambling.
Now you gave us some informa- no you just throw us some information to chew while you're writing the next chapter (I hope you keep this one alive for some time). Having little information can be a good thing while you reveal new things in chapters to come but having a main character too oblivious (even if you have reasons) puts him in a non-desirable position, he seems clueless to events going on around him even if the is living in this world for some years. He knows about school bullies but not their ambition which this girl explains later.
You said this story isnt in your confort zone so you used your previous work's template (a clueless school student explores new stuff), while I dont mind it much its better to explore new teplatates and dont get this as a bashing I just dont want you to get too repetitive (still we are in the second chapter it may be too early to make assumptions).
I also want to address the descriptions, you brutally showed us this girl is alot stronger than our MC and he is somewhat puny. After that you dont give much description. After rereading some I realised that you give much more description about the jock and nothing about the girl after their first encounter and I honestly forget about the scar or the body shape in general. What I mean is you can try subtile descriptions, like when she carried him how wind passes him realise the speed of the movement or how gracefull she was or how he get a feel of her while they are so close proximity. I know you mentioned she was athletic and we can deduce some of them but it still adds to the description or reminds us and make a lasting impression (still it is better to not to bore the reader with too much description like some authors).
Lastly this is a futa story and I still dont know why penis size is a rule of thumb on this fetish but if you combine this two in particular that is some "monster" on her and I hope you dont break the immersion of this story or the MC in half with that.
P.S: You may think some of the stuff writen above is obvious to you but I wrote those for any one to read and understand where all this coming from. Also futa is my one of my numbered fetishes which I have hard time understanding in itself, what I'm trying to say is THANK YOU for writing this one and hope you go somewhere with all these.
Author's Response: Well thanks for all the feedback! I'm not sure what to answer first. Well....
Descriptions are one thing I'm trying to work on and that's part of the reason I'm even writing this story. In my opinion, good literary erotica (porn) needs great detail to be enticing. So I'm trying.
Jericho's been described more in my mind anyway, because he's had a...well I won't call it a sex scene, but the general intent is the same. Crystal hasn't gotten that far with Remmy yet, but it's coming. She'll have her turn. I also scribbled down a bad drawing I'll be posting with the next update.
I know the school settings kind of cliche but that's not the real focus for this one. It's more a place for characters to interact than anything else, but you're right that it to mention it. I'll take that feedback.
Also know I won't be making some like 10 foot long dongzilla! Haha. There is an element of fantasy to this just based on the size difference but I am taking measure not to give exact number for stuff like that and let the reader fill in the blanks.
Don't worry I'll be writing more of this story! At least enough for the main two to get together otherwise what was the point of this?
Thanks for the comment and feedback