Reviews For Downtrodden
You must login (register) to review.
Reviewer: Barrowman Signed [Report This]
Date: July 30 2015 2:00 PM Title: Bios

I also disagree with gadgetwambo. Because she is so uninterested in her children for years. She therefor doesn't deserve to respond like that. If she was a good mother, she has a right to be angry. But she is terrible for so many years, that she must shut up and be a good parent for a change. Selfish mother.

"She’s hardly spoken to Alvin, other than to make sure he keeps the house spotless and that the cooking is done properly, she feels little to no obligation to go beyond this. It hasn’t come back to bite her in any way so why change something if it ain’t broken?"

@nostory
I can understand your point of view and that some adult might not believe you or brush it off as something light. I can understand Alvin's actions not to tell. But in this setting of events, Alvin should leave Wendy and Patricia.

Wendy and Patricia deserve eachother.



Author's Response:

Your assessment is pretty spot on , she is pretty apathetic with regards to her children.

I will have to disagree with Alvin leaving both of them, he does deserve a reformed Wendy at this point and if he chooses to stand up for by leaving Patricia, then Wendy is good enough for him. 

 

Reviewer: Carycomic Signed starstarstarstarstar [Report This]
Date: July 24 2015 10:13 AM Title: Bios

@Vgiv: in case your wondering? The slang term "snafu" goes back to World War II. At which time, it was an acronym (a word formed by initials) used sarcastically in certain radio communiques. Commissioned officers claim it stood for "Situation Normal: All Fouled Up." While enlisted men had another translation! ;-)

Today, American armed forces prefer to use the acronym "fubar" ("Fouled Up Beyond All Recognition").

Author's Response:

 Oh thanks for clearing up that Cary and it looks like I got a new word to use! Thanks for that too!

Reviewer: Barrowman Signed [Report This]
Date: July 22 2015 5:12 PM Title: Bios

@Nostory.  

"I'd just add that Wendy is not that cruel, she wouldn't intentionally do something that would kill Alvin or hurt him seriously. Even at her worst she was able to control her blows to the point that Alvin would not be hospitalised."
Isn't that because else her mother would find out what she was doing to Alvin al that time? She is sneaky too.

What do you think what she would have done if Cassie posted those photos of him and mentally break him. Would you think Wendy would mind that she totally destroyed his life? The answer is no.

And the manner how she tries to apologize to Cassie in chapter 13. That arrogant tone and how she is setting the terms of how that discussion must take place. Al her sentences make you cringe with disgust. Here we have a few.

Wendy:
“Point taken, now can we talk in a more private place? My personal life isn’t supposed to be broadcasted to the entire school,” Cassie relaxed her grip which gave Wendy an idea.
“No matter how much you think it, I’m a not monster. At least, I didn’t start out as one, no ever becomes one just like that,” Wendy snapped her finger.
“ Thank you Cassie, it’s the first nice thing you’ve done for me,”
“ I’d like to continue, if that’s fine with you,”


I don't mind. I like those discussions and different views. I'm also interested in the view the writer has.

 



Author's Response:

That and the laws covering the abuse of a smaller size leave you with no room to breathe once you get caught. 

 

If Cassie had done that, Wendy wouldn't have been bothered at all, she'd just go right in and laugh at him. 

You're probably going to ask, why doesn't Alvin report Wendy to the police then? Or any adult to get rid of her? 

As a victim of bullying, I tell you its not that easy and even after I did , the adult either didn't do enough or brushed it off as teasing and told me to be less sensitive. After a while you just learn to put up with it, that's it. 

It was supposed to be in a more sympathetic light, the first part especially of the quotes you brought up but it could be due to my subpar description of the scene that led you to believe otherwise. the third line too. In fact all of these are supposed to be from a girl trying to be polite. 

I've always wanted to write a story that got the readers into discussions with either each other or the writers involved. 

 

 

 

Reviewer: Barrowman Signed [Report This]
Date: July 22 2015 8:10 AM Title: Bios

@vgiv. I too am an only child. I hold friendships and family in high regard. But check out how short that period was where she supposedly loved him and how long that time was when she tortured him. When his father died, there was no love for him in that house.
That last act of her was nasty. She knew that would destroy him. She didn't even worry when he didn't came home and probably would have liked it when Cassie would had gone trough with her plan for Alvin. She would'nt have cared if died.

When he comes home. See the way she talks to him. Not satisfied because Cassie didn't mentally destroyed him with is not far away from killing someone. Sounds pretty sadistic to me.
Those eight years of torture just because of a few words Alvin said?

Maybe you see something in Wendy that makes it worth it to give her a chance. But I wouldn't if I were in Alvin's shoes. That boat sailed away a long time ago. Just leaving them isn't even an evil act compared to the eight years of torture and lack of love.

 

 

 

 



Author's Response:

I'd just add that Wendy is not that cruel, she wouldn't intentionally do something that would kill Alvin or hurt him seriously. Even at her worst she was able to control her blows to the point that Alvin would not be hospitalised. Bullying Alvin is a drug for her, she feels powerful doing it and it masks her insecurities. 

I'm not against what you feel about Wendy since I was trying to get people to hate her when I wrote it and not believing her turnaround is expected. I totally respect your point of view, you and everyone have good reason to be skeptical of her. 

Reviewer: vgiv Signed starstarstarstarstar [Report This]
Date: July 21 2015 2:54 PM Title: Bios

@Barrowman true enough on the first part, I did miss that as I have not read the first chapter in a while, but when you consider that Wendy and Alvin did have a rather happy relationship before she began harrassing him, as Nostory at one point mentioned that when she hugged him after they made up it was the first real hug she had given him in a while, meaning that they cared for each other. I may be an only child, but I know that a brother and sister bond, or any bond among siblings is something hard to forget.

If Alvin does leave the house, good for him, he'll never know his sister again. Leaving both Wendy and Patricia is the equivalent of hatred. By all means, Wendy has a few good reasons to love Alvin dearly. Her miserable life growing up without Daniel and Alvin changed for the better when he showed up.

Speaking of which, another possible explanation for Wendy's behavior was that she was bullied as a kid, for being un-Amazonian, and people who are bullied often become bullies themsleves. Wendy began bullying Alvin after a joke he made about her appearence, so Wendy bullied Alvin, the way an the son of a abusive father bullies his peers. While it is still cruelty, it is not because Wendy has a sadistic heart, as you imply, it is because she is also a victim. She at least deserves a chance from Alvin.

@Nostory I only speak English, sorry, but I know a few people who speak German, and some that speak Spanish.



Author's Response:

Could those people help with Spanish translations? Not keen to use Google translate with its too literal translations. 

Plus have you read the email I sent? Sorry but I really need a reply on it, I'll also explain the scenes that require Spanish.

 

Reviewer: Barrowman Signed [Report This]
Date: July 21 2015 1:20 PM Title: Bios

@vgiv,
"as they did have a civilised conversation in Alvin's car in Chapter 1 I think"

Wendy:" I don’t get why Mom always asks you more questions. Am I that uninteresting?”
Alvin: "I don’t know. Honestly, sometimes I wonder why she gets so quiet every time I say the word scholarship?"
Wendy: "Alvin,"
Alvin: "Yes sister dear?"
Wendy:"Try not to make it too easy for my friends I to push you around. We like a challenge"

That was the conversation in the car. A civilised promise of a massive beating like she had done so many times before. Impressing her friends has nothing to do with it, because she is the leader of the group. You can clearly see from the behaviour of her friends that they don't care about beating Alvin up or not. They already respected her and she already stands out.
That guy cooks for her and doesn't look for trouble. But eight years long, abuse inside the house and at school non-stop. She is either cruel or stupid or both or something in between. That behaviour would have continued if Cassy hadn't befriend him and treathened her multiple times.

If he leaves the house, he is finally rid of Wendy and her mother. No more stress and a good life ahead. No need to hate them either, just erase them completely from your life. Don't give them your phone-number, don't tell them where you live. Move as far way as possible. Wendy and Patricia deserve eachother.



Author's Response:

Damn I forgot about that line...

Might have made Wendy a lot creepier than I intended there. 

Reviewer: vgiv Signed [Report This]
Date: July 21 2015 2:37 AM Title: Bios

@Barrowman to be fair, Wendy never seemed to be completley malevolent to Alvin, not exactly cruel or sadistic, as they did have a civilised conversation in Alvin's car in Chapter 1 I think, Wendy only got cruel in the prescence of her friends, and admittedly, we all do act harsher or differently when around friends. Either to impress them, stand out, or because we are human we feel more comfortable and lax around others naturally, so your sense of decorum and judgement are impaired.

@Nostory I will check my inbox but for some reason my notifactions don't work anymore. So I don't know when I have been emailed.



Author's Response:

I've had that before.Perhaps you could try checking your inbox at the start of the day and once more at the end, bound to have stuff. This does explain why you didn't respond to the last two emails at all. By the way, are you  fluent in any language besides English? I could use a translator for some of my stories. I'll explain it in an email when you reply to mine. 

We've all been guilty of behaving like that at some point, caving in to peer pressure and I am sure Wendy plays it up when she has to, for fear of being questioned by her friends on why she hasn't been doing that. Its still her fault since she started the whole thing but its a trap many people fall in to. At home she at the very least ignores him unless he has done something to warrant a beating. In school her friends admitted to following her when going after Alvin, they'd have done nothing if she had stopped so its all peer pressure and not wanting to be the odd one out. 

You got 27 reviews to go in your quest, I'll be sure to congratulate you if you become the 200th reviewer. Should it happen. 

 

Reviewer: Barrowman Signed [Report This]
Date: July 20 2015 11:09 PM Title: Bios

@Nostory. You have point. And it's not unrealistic either, but she is still creepy. Acting so nice after many years of complete opposite behaviour. That character can't be gone. She good easely fall back to being rotten again if Cassie was gone. It's best if Alvin moved out of that house as soon as possible, just to be sure. He can go live with Cassie and leave al his troubles behind.

 



Author's Response:

All of what you mentioned are valid concerns and it is up to Alvin to trust Wendy, he and Wendy had good times before the bad so Alvin has to put his faith in that Wendy still has good in her. 

There's still 9 chapters to see if Alvin chose poorly and the story ends with him in a ditch, body mangled from Wendy's fatal beating. She is an Amazon and while they don't have the strength a Titan has, it wouldn't be too hard for them to a man or normal woman with their fists. 

Reviewer: vgiv Signed [Report This]
Date: July 20 2015 3:35 PM Title: Bios

I like how Alvin turns around in the middle of his sprint. Like there is no chance of tripping then getting owned by the concrete.

Wendy is proving to be more of smartmouth yet loving older sister, rather than a younger one which she is. I suppose it is the Amazon blood.



Author's Response:

  Oh that would have been painful to watch. Yeah its the Amazon side of her , her size can make Alvin look like her younger brother. 

Reviewer: Barrowman Signed [Report This]
Date: July 20 2015 1:28 PM Title: Bios

@Nostory

I've read it to chapter 18. I find her behaviour patterns very disturbing. ;) First normal treatment when his dad was alive, than super cruel for a long time and than be able to have selfreflection at her friends house and with Cassie and after that acting nice to Alvin. She wasn't only cruel to Alvin, but to others too for years. Wendy left him in a life treathening situation with Titans. That rotten character can't be gone in just a few moments off talk with Cassie.

 

 



Author's Response:

Hmm good point but remember she went through quite a few ass kickings from Cassie before their talk so she has the bruises to show for that, her turnaround isn't just because of a few words. 

Reviewer: Barrowman Signed starstarstarstar [Report This]
Date: July 20 2015 9:34 AM Title: Bios

Fun story of day to day school life in a world full of Titans and Amazons. But I miss a size class between Amazon and Titan. Something around 15 metres to 20 metres.

Wendy is creepy. I don't know what to make of her. Patricia Mathers is a typical bad mother.

 

 

 



Author's Response:

Thanks for reviewing!

vgiv came up with the sizes, I just followed the rules set by him for those. I might do a story set with a 50-60 foot giantess but outside of this series. 

Patricia defintiely not Mother of the Year, its obvious but how far have you read? Wendy isn't always creepy.

Reviewer: White Wolf Signed [Report This]
Date: June 06 2015 10:21 AM Title: Bios

Love the story, and a Bio "chapter" is a great idea, but if I have a minor criticism, it would be the use of photos of real people for the characters.  I like to be able to use my imagination when I picture a character in a story, and once I get a real-life person in my head from a photo, it creats a bit of dissonance for me to visualize the characters.  Also, there are the inevitable differences between the models in the photos and the characters as described in the story.  e.g. Cassie's breast size compared to the supermodel pictured.

Sorry, I hope that wasn't harsh.  I'm just trying to offer support for the criticism.  

Loving the story though, and your idea to provide a nice easy reference chapter for the character descriptions is genius.  



Author's Response:

Okay, I see your point and I think if you do not want to follow the pictures then go ahead and create your own image of the characters. 

That part about cup sizes is why I tried to get a good picture of Nina Agdal that doesn't show her whole body, so I could state that she is a bustier girl. 

 

I can't claim credit for the idea though, I think TinyDann is the one who started it with Carrie's Science Project 2.

Reviewer: greaterthan3 Signed starstarstarstarstar [Report This]
Date: June 03 2015 9:59 AM Title: Bios

Heh, looks like the title of the story is not just reffering to Alvin.  It's a good thing Cassie has good friends understanding of what Alvin whent through.  As much fun as it would be to have a 15 for or 100+ foot girlfriend I don't think i could be ultimately happy in a world like this.

 

Men and normal sized women are powerless here, it would be depressing going through life knowing no matter what you do you would never be able to stop a titan or amazon if you tried.


HopefuHopefully in the end it works out for Alvin, my hope is Wendy eventually tells her mom off to defend Alvin and he forgives her.  I also am hoping for Alvin and Cassie to get together officially and maybe have s fun night :p



Author's Response:

Correct, the title isn't just referring to Alvin, it has always referred to a few people at once. 

Well you have a point, this is a world where normals( which includes men and unaffected women) are at a severe disadvantage when there are women twice your height or the size of buildings walking around, their physical bodies make it so easy to pick on a smaller size. However, there are still families where the smaller sizes don't get tortured or bullied , we tend to write these because it is what makes the stories interesting. I don't mind a simple story where we see a Titans or Amazons are nice to their smaller counterparts but maybe not yet, plus I am not sure if I can do without making it boring. May try it after this.

Just know that nice Titans and Amazons exist out there plus . Cassie isn't too bad is she? Apart from that fourth chapter. Also, not even Titans are immune to all the bullying and pain, you'll find out over the course of the series, they are not one women armies. Guns do hurt them, knives too. 

Reviewer: Darien Fawkes Signed starstarstarstarstar [Report This]
Date: May 29 2015 7:13 PM Title: Bios

I just read the last few chapters in one sitting, since they mainly revolve around Wendy and her character, that will  be what I address.

On the surface I'll be honest, her backstory looks pretty generic. Child who grows up with parents who don't want her, and a drunk wifebeater for a father. At first it sounds like every other backstory that's been done before. What makes this different, however, is in the number of layers within this story. The mother not wanting children explains her indifference to Wendy and Alvin (along with the death of Daniel), giving Wendy parental issues. The father beating Wendy gave her a sense of helplessness that she would channel into Alvin, becoming a bully. But what I found even more interesting than that, is how she was beaten during her developing years. This stunned her growth, as well as kept her from developing any imressive curves or muscles. So not only did Wendy grow up being abused, but she also had to deal with self-image issues. Not to mention the bullying at the hands of a bigger Amazon. So she's delt with neglect, abuse, and self-image issues.

Finally, what made this story way different from other generic my-drunk-dad-beat-me backstories, is Wendy's past history with Alvin. It's so refreshing to see that they had a legitimate brother-sister relationship. It's like learning that, when they were kids, Cinderella's step sisters were close friends of hers. It makes their present relationship more interesting, and gives more character and depth to Wendy and Alvin.

I do have one problem, and that is the build up. A lot of people tell me that in my story A New Perspective, they weren't sure how to handle Peter's battle with depression, because they felt like it was too much revelation at once. Some say that they felt it came out of no where, and they had a point. I probably should have dropped a few more hints here and there. This story gave me a new point of view to consider, as the reader. While Wendy's story was great, it felt like too much to learn at once. That story you illustrated earlier, where Wendy erases all of Alvin's contacts? If you had a few more flash back scenes like that earlier in the story, it would have been perfect. Then there would have been that perfect balance between giving a deeper look into a character, while keeping us guessing. Then you tell the whole story when Wendy speaks to Cassie. 

My final thoughts: great backstory, very deep with history and experience, and answered some questions. Though there should have been more flash back scenes to show us the past first hand rather than tell all at once. Please don't take that as critisism though, as I'm guilty of the same mistake. Looking forward to the next instalment.



Author's Response:

Wow, the longest review of the update. Okay, lets take this in and respond. 

You're right, her backstory for the most part is generic and I actually thought it would be enough. I realised after a while some people bully others because they are the victims of bullying and need an outlet to vent their frustrations and/or to feel strong. However I did know that if it was only the father, then Wendy's development into the monster she is today would have been unrealistic because there was nothing to it. So I thought it best she be constantly hit with the idea of how weak and worthless she is, from parents who never wanted her to girls who picked on her. It never occured to me to think this was overkill but it seems to have paid off, a bully created out of a perfect storm.

I think for there to even be a chance of the reader believing Alvin and Wendy could get back together, they had to have some good times, as a base to build on. It would be like Ben reaching out to Amy but without him ever having a crush on her, it seems strange other than to think he is just a saint or something. Whether Alvin and Wendy do get back together, you'll have to wait. 

Okay, I never hinted at much was because I thought it would be surprising to the reader to know that things weren't always so horrible with the step siblings, it would be a surprise twist. Downtrodden is essentially based off a very smutty idea I had which borrows from Cinderella, I'll reveal a bit after I end Downtrodden but I'll say Downtrodden is like the grandchild of the Cinderella story I had. So your analogy is quite fitting. 

Another thing is that I conceived Downtrodden in the summer of 2014, dusting off an idea while rebooting The Escape and Aftermath, two poorly planned out stories but Aftermath was too draggy. I gave flashbacks liberally but the story seemed to be too slow. vgiv and I worked to make sure this story would have excitement with a little break here and there to allow for some breathing. I thought to give Wendy a flashback would be dragging it down. I was also a little down, wondering why people weren't loving Aftermath as I thought they should be but I learnt a few valuable lessons during that period and am putting it to use now. 

For the sake of experimentation, I got one more character to delve into and I'll use flashbacks for that, see which one comes out better. Wendy's or the other person. Then I'll put the lessons learnt from this into my next story in this series. That one requires a good deal of flashbacks. 

Thanks for this detailed reviews, really helped. 

Also, for the record, I think you did it well on A New Perspective , the battle with depression wasn't totally out there because you kept dropping these little paragraphs hinting at a darker force within. Its just that readers didn't pick up on it too much. Don't be too harsh on yourself, it was a good story. 

 

Reviewer: gadgetmawombo Signed [Report This]
Date: May 29 2015 4:09 PM Title: Bios

Oh, I just figured you were ending it soon. I'd say we have 4 chapters left? I don't know. I hope this story goes on for a while longer, this is definitely my favorite of your stories!



Author's Response:

I'd say about 8 or so, maybe more if I have to. So you'll be happy to know there's at least 8 more planned chapters.

Reviewer: tinyguy Signed starstarstarstarstar [Report This]
Date: May 20 2015 7:04 PM Title: Bios

Great chapter as always! Very interesting to hear Wendy's backstory. Wonder if we'll hear Cassie's backstory anytime soon?

Also wondering if there's gonna be any more Titans in the story?

Author's Response:

Maybe, Wendy did reveal the backstory for not only her but Patricia and Alvin as well. 

Hmmm...should I tell you? Okay I wil, it won't spoil the story much anywayl. Yes, there will be more Titans. 

Reviewer: SoleEmbrace Signed [Report This]
Date: May 14 2015 12:01 AM Title: Bios

Wee, looks like Wendy's have a change of heart...maybe? :p We'll see how Alvin handles it!



Author's Response:

Thanks for reviewing, I don't know. Did she? 

Reviewer: MadHatter Signed [Report This]
Date: May 13 2015 12:03 AM Title: Bios

I'm glad to see this isn't dead. This is like I've said in a few reviews before, one of the few stories where the story is more interesting then the fetish content. Keep goin man! I wanna see this conclusion :-D



Author's Response:

Thanks, I got it all planned out so its just a matter of having time to write. I promise you that you will see the story come to an end. 

Reviewer: tinyguy Signed [Report This]
Date: April 20 2015 9:17 AM Title: Bios

Any updates Soon?

Author's Response:

I have exams, not exactly easy to update but after my last paper its the long summer break which I intend to use to update all my active stories. Downtrodden is more or less fully planned out, no writer's block there. The Escape is fully plotted and Dance was done a long time ago so no problems with planning, just execution. 

Reviewer: vgiv Signed [Report This]
Date: March 31 2015 11:56 AM Title: Bios

Fifty Shades is not at all the same kind of stuff that goes on this site. It was actually originally a fanfiction the author wrote about Twilight, then changed the names. It is a dreadful movie...



Author's Response:

Haven't seen the movie and I don't plan on seeing it but I agree. 

You must login (register) to review.