Reviews For A new beginning
You must login (register) to review.
Reviewer: Shaman Signed starstarstarstarstar [Report This]
Date: January 06 2024 10:56 PM Title: A New Week (Part 4)

Really interesting so far! Gonna be a joy reading the rest!



Author's Response:

Thanks for reading! I'm glad you enjoyed the story!

I hope that you will like the rest of the story just as much!

Reviewer: It Was Me Signed starstarstarstarstar [Report This]
Date: December 26 2023 8:32 PM Title: A New Week (Part 4)

The more we see of Shana, the more impressed I am at how you're able to make me view her so differently from how I did at the start of this story.

I mean, she hasn't really changed the way she acts or even speaks at all from the early chapters, and she hasn't had some sort of life-changing revelation to change the way she thinks or views the world, either. No, she's exactly the same as she was from the start. And yet, I find her so much more likable now, and she has gone from being a bully to someone I want to root for.

I know you said before that you were worried that Shana's "turn" might seem forced and unnatural, but the exact opposite is true. She's every bit the same as she was when we first met her, but a deeper understanding of who she is has radically changed my perception of her words and actions. I've said it before, but I can't say enough how blown away I am by that.

And this chapter is a perfect example. Without those chapters that showed Shana lightly (barely at all, but just enough) touching on her deeper feelings with her teammates, Shana would have come off as a hateful jerk for the way she handled the situation with Maya, despite the fact that she bought her food. But now, she can say things like, "If you open your mouth on the way, I swear I will strangle you and throw you in a ditch," and my reaction is to chuckle a bit and think, "Oh, silly Shana."

In other words, I can see beyond the hateful tone her words imply and see that she's really trying to be a good big sister. She just doesn't know how to do that, and the spite she puts out there is really just a defense mechanism. It's really interesting, and I find myself liking and sympathizing with her more and more each time she says something that seems terrible on the outside. I also find myself really hoping she can find a good way to actually express herself by the end of the story.

As for Maya, this was a pretty eye-opening chapter regarding her character. I've found it odd for a while now that Maya acts a bit younger than 13 quite often in this story, but I've mostly attributed that to the kind of silly, almost zany undertone you've inserted into this story, which does give it some much-appreciated levity. But after reading this chapter, I feel like it actually makes sense for her character now.

Seeing the lonely life that Maya lives (outside of Emily), with her mother always away and seemingly trying to parent strictly through parental controls and limiting Maya's access to things, I can understand why Maya acts so young and finds comfort in things that maybe some 13-year-olds would find to be a bit childish. She didn't have a role model to aspire to be until Emily came into the picture (which couldn't have been more than what, two or three years ago at most?), so her idea of what is and isn't childish is different from most (there are also times where she shows some advanced maturity for her age as well).

This is especially sad when you realize that that very role model was always present in Shana, but the elder sister's inability to properly convey her feelings has made that impossible. Not to mention that Shana's conflict with Maya's mother (and from what we've read here, I'm starting to think that Shana is right about her) has clearly driven a huge wedge between the two sisters. I can see now why Shana was so happy (whether or not she would ever admit it directly) that Maya found Shana, as well as why Shana wants Maya to make up with Emily.

I also understand why Maya deleted Emily's text. In a normal situation, that wouldn't have made a lot of sense, but seeing as how most of Maya's personal interactions have likely been with Shana, it makes perfect sense that she would assume that Emily would send her a randomly hateful text because she was mad at her. That sounds like something an unhinged Shana would do, after all.

So I can understand why the thought of reading something spiteful from her much older crush would be too much for her heart to bare.

With all of that being said, I'm really curious to see how this conversation between Emily, Shana, Maya and (most likely, I would think) Jane is going to go down. You've done a wonderful job with these last four or so chapters in building anticipation for this (and other confrontations to come, I'm sure).



Author's Response:

Thank you for reviewing and sorry for taking so long to respond.


Firstly, I'm glad you liked Shana. I'm also glad that you find her 'change' believable, even if it's just a change of perspective, and that this makes you react completely different, even if she acts the same as before.

Being able to write a story that is appreciated, with characters that are considered interesting, is something I'm really happy about. This is my first experience writing for someone other than myself (as my first story proves), and that makes this year's experience even more rewarding.

I had doubts about making Maya's mother an absent mother because I thought it was too similar to Suki, but a bit like Jane and Nadia, I thought about making a parallel that they had a similar past, but Suki wasn't lucky enough to have a grumpy sister who secretly wanted to help her, nor an Emily of her own, which unfortunately made her who she is.

The next chapter, the conversation between the four (where I reveal some of the many hidden truths between them), marks the beginning of what should theoretically be the final arc of the story. So I'm going to take some time and try to make it as good as I possibly can.


Thank you again for reading and reviewing. I wish you (belatedly) a Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year!

You must login (register) to review.