Reviewer: Sg20855 Signed
Date: May 10 2016
Title: Chapter 19: Chapter 19: Sister vs. Brother
Amazing chapter, absolutely loved it, and I'm grateful for the quick update. You wrote Carly perfectly for this chapter. You captured her somewhat psychotic and twisted love and passion for Jack, one of my favorite characteristics about her, extremely well. When the chapter was building up to Carly talking about getting her life back together with Jack, part of me was hoping for Jack to reciprocate Carly's twisted love for him, but I'm also glad Jack stood up for himself and threw down the ultimatum at Carly that he will never be her property again. The emotions Carly displayed of sadness, longing and desire before Jack's ultimatum, as well as her break down and anguish afterwards were also really well done, some of the best writing to date. Although as you said, Carly is not out of this yet, and it'll be interesting to see what will happen with her next. Also wonder what will happen with Jack now, as well as Sophie. Before the whole kidnapping, I was predicting/hoping Jack would develop a relationship with Sophie where Jack finds resolution for, and satisfies, his lust and desire for feet, but still retaining his humanity since its with someone who actually loves and cares for him in an honest and positive way. But after the reintroduction of Carly, I dunno what to expect/ what I want to happen, but I trust where you will take this story. Amazing work so far, always glad to read your work.
Author's Response:
Thanks for the in depth review! The hint of a lustful relationship with Sophie's feet at the end of that other chapter was more to symbolize Jack's residual need to resolve things with Carly, but I can understand the expectation there. I like to keep people guessing.