Reviewer: sanguine tangerine Signed 



Date: February 12 2025
Title: Chapter 1: Callie vs. the Minimalist Mini
I read Roomies, and I liked it! I'll be re-reading and reviewing chapter-by-chapter until I run out of steam.
A very classic opening to a "tiny person in my house" story, but I like how quickly you establish Callie's character. Upset with life, but deep down, she's a fighter.
I think it's a little surprising that Duncan is so quick to open up to Callie about his recent past, but narratively it probably works better than waiting for them to build up more trust.
The squirrel fight was treated with a lot of levity considering it was almost a gruesome death. Maybe laughter is the only way you can deal with such an experience.
The shoebox was another excellent way to build Callie's character. She's crafty, resourceful, and cares about the comfort of others. Duncan's response was disappointingly muted in comparison.
I feel like we have a good idea of Callie's personality at this point, but it's less clear if Duncan is really that brave, or if he's traumatized to numbness or putting on a brave face. I would be pretty messed up if I had gone through what he had endured. Duncan's character feels underdeveloped - we know a lot about what happened to him, but we still don't know who he is.
I also felt like this chapter failed to establish a central conflict for the story, but I'll probably dig into that more in a future review.
Overall, I thought this was a solid, if somewhat generic way to introduce the characters. We got a bit of a lore, and we are starting to see who they are.
Author's Response: Hey! I'm glad you enjoyed the story and that you decided to go through it again and review each chapter! Sorry for taking so long to respond, but I've had a lot going on of late. I'll get to each chapter review from you though!
You're dead on about the "tiny person in my house" thing. Very early in my thinking this up, I wanted to take a classic, clichéd theme like this and try to do something different with it, freshen up the concept.
I love that Callie resonated with you right away, and you're exactly right about her. She's in a bad place at this point, but she's staying true to herself and trying to power through it rather than letting it bog her down and reshape her attitude. Actually, this adversity, in a lot of ways, has only strengthened who she is, as it made her want to help Duncan even more rather than shut down and focus on her own problems.
Reading all of your reviews, it seems a lot of what I tried to do with Duncan didn't quite resonate with you. That sucks to read as an author, but I really appreciate the feedback. I'll go back and try to reevaluate some things and see how I could have made some things clearer with him, so that I can convey some of those things through my future characters more broadly.
As for Duncan sharing his story with Callie, it was more out of a desperation to connect with someone after six months of almost complete isolation from humanity than trust that he did that. Granted, he did spend a week testing her after observing her before that, so he was fairly confident that she was a good person, especially after she went out of her way to feed him and make him feel like a person again (talking to him through the wall). But Duncan doesn't trust easy, both because of what happened after he shrank and his life in general before that.
I didn't rush this for narrative reasons, though. Between Duncan's state of mind here and Callie having earned the moment through her actions, I thought it developed pretty naturally. Again, I feel like the disconnect here is that I didn't do a good enough job of showing off his mental state at the time. Sorry about that.
A lot of Duncan's story was told very casually by him because of his general state of mind as his journey progressed, which doesn't really get explained until later. I was hoping that the way he told some parts of the story like this compared to the part about Kristie would help emphasize that, at some point, he just kind of accepted things as they came and decided to just roll with it, using the trauma of whatever Kristie did to show that he does, in fact, have limits to that levity and that some things really do linger within him.
So the squirrel fight, by the time it happened, was past that point for Duncan. So much shit had happened to him at that point that it barely even registers as a near-death experience to him anymore. Every day came with those, and rather than lose his mind by living in constant fear, he just kind of stopped worrying about it and decided that he was at peace of today was the day he died. So that's why he comes off more embarrassed than traumatized when he tells this story.
Also, Callie adds to the levity a lot, finding the story cute and funny at first. As a normal-sized person, the thought of a tiny person fighting a squirrel for food doesn't immediately register as dangerous, I think. It's just such a hard thing to empathize with. But there was a point when she realized how big a thing this actually was and that he could have actually died, and she got serious in that moment. Then Duncan's method of escape brought humor back into the picture.
I'm happy the shoebox scene came off the way I wanted it to. I really wanted to show how resourceful and competent she was, as that comes into play several times throughout the story (such as with Duncan's clothes, his gym, how his shoebox house eventually turns out, etc.). And yeah, she's all about making others feel comfortable, especially someone like Duncan, who has been through hell. Not to mention that she feels like helping Duncan is somewhat therapeutic for herself, making her feel less useless as her problems seem so far out of reach for her.
I think Duncan's response to Callie here makes a lot of sense for the character. He appreciates what she's doing for him, sure, but he's also very cautious. Again, he doesn't trust easily, and we already know that one other person who found him treated him with kindness as well only to turn around and torture him later on. So while I get that a lot of people would have had a big reaction to her effort, I think his approach was perfect for where he's at right now. Plus, he did thank her and go out of his way to make her feel better about the arrangements being less than ideal by her own standards (him mentioning that he had slept in a hole in the wall for the past month).
Yeah, Callie's more of an open-book type, while Duncan is a lot more guarded. It's by design that we're still trying to figure out more about who he really is at this point. Like you said, we know a lot about what happened to him, but a good amount of time is spent throughout this story showing how those things affected him and who they made him become.
As for the lack of central conflict thing, yeah, I kind of slow roll everything out. This chapter was more about establishing the premise for the story and getting the reader familiar with these characters than giving them a problem to solve.
So yeah, I'm glad you seemed to mostly like the first chapter. And I really appreciate your honesty. I don't necessarily agree with everything you said here, it's certainly given me a lot to think about!