Date: October 19 2024 4:12 AM Title: Chapter 5 - Tiny Sampler Platter for Two
I'm currently halfway through Chapter 5, but I figure I should get my current thoughts out now because who knows what's coming in these last few chapters. Sorry it's taking me so long to catch up. Never has a story required me to take so many breaks while reading, if you catch my drift. You've really outdone yourself with this one!
First off, the prose is absolutely oozing with sensuality in every sentence. Word choice, alliteration, dialogue (Oh my God the dialogue), everything comes together to put the reader on the wildest ride of their life. A standout moment is in I think chapter 4 where Amaterasu whispers into Beth's ear and there's an entire paragraph dedicated to how her breath feels on Beth's ear and that's just one of many examples of next level smut writing on display here. No stone is left unturned, no sensory detail left untouched. This story is constantly blowing me away.
I believe I said it in my last review, but it needs saying again that Beth is incredible. Now that I've gotten into the meat of the vorgy, she makes such an excellent pred. There's so much depth to her, a woman who is madly in love with a tiny gal and eager to mercilessly devour other little ladies in the same breath, and that complexity adds to every tease, every threat, every justification, and every empty promise that drips out of her ravenous mouth. The way she manipulates her snackrifices into fearing her in the exact way she wants, the way that best serves her libido, is a sight to behold, and I love the way she justifies killing them by rationalizing her gluttonous indulgence as giving them a chance at achieving ultimate pleasure before they die. It's not that she's doing them a service by eating them, but if they're going to die for her pleasure, they may as well enjoy it. It's twisted, compelling, and extremely hot. And the fact it contrasts so hard with how caring and gentle we see her act towards Cassidy (gentle in the streets, maybe not so much in the sheets) further heightens her character's appeal (at least to me, the reader, maybe not so much to the people she's eating). When Alma called her a monster that hit so hard, because she is one and yet you have me rooting for her unapologetically. Their little lives be damned, I want to see Beth satisfied!
That insight into Cass' backstory, talking about how she met Beth, did a lot to flesh out her character. The fact she at one point was so despondent she actually wanted Beth to eat her, to serve a greater purpose as extra fat on her tits, really stuck with me. Initially, Cass came off to me as a callous nympho, someone who doesn't care about loss of life if it gets her and her giant girlfriend off, and I guess that's kinda still true, but the fact she doesn't value her own life to begin with really clarifies why she's eager to feed her sloppy seconds to her lover. She's not exactly a hypocrite if she's willing to share in their fate! And I love Beth having to tell Cass that she has to hold back with her, that tonight the cravings might become too strong and she does the unthinkable.
Also, if I ever have to explain to someone what the appeal of getting vored is, I'm showing them Cass' explanation from chapter 4. It so perfectly sums up the fantasy and what I love about it in a way I'm not sure I could accomplish on my own, at least not as well worded as this.
I'll admit that race play isn't usually my cup of tea, but I think having the tinies all be flavored based on their heritage works really well here (Pushpa tasting like Indian food, the German girl reminding Beth of Oktoberfest, etc.) Tinies having distinct flavors is always a treat, and it also serves the additional purpose of making the ladies easily identifiable which is no easy feat when there's like a dozen of them. I also like how they each react differently to imminent threat of being devoured. Momo accepts it early on (I loved that tender moment with her sister as she poked out of Beth's lips and the giant woman pushing her twin against her throat as she swallowed), Adeya fights it the whole way down, Alma freaks out, then accepts it, then relates to Beth through the game they both play, only to return to freaking out once she's actually travelling down the esophagus. The range on these minor characters is incredible and adds layers to what would be literal fodder in a lesser story.
On a semi-related note, I need to know what kind of game Gut Slut Grotto is. I'm guessing some mobile gacha crap from the things the characters said, but what's the gameplay like, and how can I get an actual developer to make it a reality?
I think I covered most of what I wanted to say, though I'm probably forgetting a bunch of praise worthy points, but I guess there's still three and a half chapters left, so expect another review or two down the road. This story is really outstanding, and I'm so glad your PC is back to get it uploaded (and I'll let you know I am dying to read more Small Investments. Why'd your PC have to break on a cliffhanger, dammit?!)
Author's Response:
I'm not gonna lie, I'm not giving this review the response it deserves. I just spent an hour and a half overloading my brain, trying to figure out how to properly thank It Was Me for that glowing review on Chapter 5. I finally hit a point where I don't feel like complete crap for failing to appropriately address all of the details mentioned, so I hit Submit on the response - only to see this incredible review pop up. I feel like an anime character who just came out of the mid-season finale, clothes torn, one arm hanging useless, 8 people's worth of my blood laying splattered on the shattered stones behind me, only for the boss of the next arc to show up and pull off a grandmaster-tier technique that blasts me through a mountain, just to show me how freaking far I have yet to go before I might have a chance of meeting them on the field of battle.
Screw it. Shonen power of muscle-headed determination, activate!
I'm glad the sensuality hasn't gotten stale. As several of the tinies find out next chapter, too much of a good thing is a thing that happens, regardless of whether you still want more afterwards. I'm doing my damnedest to make sure it's still fresh and enjoyable, but after enough chapters of almost non-stop sex, that natural sensitivity boost could easily become grating. As for the whispers thing, I feel like the sensuality of the intimately spoken desire is an element of erotica that is criminally underutilized in size fiction. I very much wanted to make use of it here, particularly during significant high points, or potential turning points.
I'm glad Beth is still flying high in your eyes. She's definitely not a self-insert character, but she is definitely serving as a vessel for those intrusive thoughts and desires that, should shrinking/growing ever become possible, I expect I would be too principled to act on, but would be torn up inside by the allure of the taboo. I have loved taking the hollow justifications and strawman arguments I've made playing devil's advocate in my own head, and filling them out and expressing them through this ravenous, yet empathetic temptress. That monster comment was one I agonized over for a while. Not whether or not Alma would call Beth a monster, but rather how she would handle it. In the end, taking it in stride seemed like the right call. Beth has seen what normals do to tinies, and has second-hand experience through Cassidy of what it can be like. She has acknowledged her desires are monstrous, and accepted that she is, in some ways, a monster. That doesn't mean she can't still love Cassidy, nor does it mean she has to hold herself back from her deepest, darkest desires. She has accepted that she is a monster, and as such, she gets to have more fun.
Ah, the appeal of Vore. I rewrote that explanation like 3 times. It's such a strange thing, how it plays with our instincts in a way that's almost counter to evolution. I'm glad it landed, and if you ever do actually use it to try and explain the appeal of vore, I hope it serves you - and any other readers who might try the same - well.
I'm with you on raceplay. It's not a major factor for me, but rather I do find the cultural differences, and the different perspectives they each have, to be appealing. Those cultural differences just so happen to tend to come with some aesthetic physiological differences that can help visually remind the reader of those cultural differences in the context of this story. Plus, I know some people are into that, so I play it up a little here.
Ah, Gut Slut Grotto. I 1000% pictured it as a sizey gatcha game with a focus on collecting the various gut sluts, ostensibly to flush out a story, much like an interactive visual novel. Different GS's would have different stats, and which ones you used in different circumstances would give different story arcs, and eventually different endings.
Once again, thank you so much for taking the time to comment. Once I'm done with posting this story, I'm going to take the time to dive back into Twin Sizes and Roomies, before I do my Small Investments readthrough. I'm looking forward to checking in on the excitement of the cute tiny with a HUGE personality, her quiet, giant sister, and of course, the shenanigans of the infamous love rhombus.
Date: October 17 2024 4:28 PM Title: Chapter 5 - Tiny Sampler Platter for Two
Damn, I'm too slow (in my defense this chapter is even longer than one of mine)! I see that you got the next chapter up, but I just finished reading this one. I've got a lot to say about it, though, so I'm not going to peek at the new one until I'm done writing this review.
First and foremost, your word choices! That's it. That's the sentence!
I don't know if it comes naturally to you or if you agonize over most of the words used in a given chapter like I do, but holy tits did every God damned word in this chapter seem carefully crafted to make the subject matter they were being used to describe as sexy as humanly possible. I'm talking about the words used, the way they all seem to work in concert with one another to paint just the right picture the reader, the creativity in which some word definitions are stretched just enough to make them fit, and even the words in different languages! This isn't unusual in your work to a certain extent, but my mind was blown by how much you stepped up your game here. Impressed isn't a strong enough word.
There are so many descriptive phrases that I love scattered throughout the chapter that I can't name them here. It would take too long.
Then there were a couple of times in this chapter that left me repeatedly asking myself, "How the fuck did he do that?" There's so much going on all the time, and you balance out all the action so well, so clearly and easy to visualize, and with personality bursting from each character throughout all of it. I'm reading these scenes and yet I can't comprehend how you not only kept all of this together but made every part of it seem so special and unique.
I'm still loving the fuck out of Beth imagining what the vorgy is like inside her stomach! Some of them aren't even based on what she's feeling in there, like how she was so sure that they took Alma as she was screaming and put her face in someone's pussy to calm her down. It's so fucking cute in the hottest way possible! Between that and you being on point with her feeling them shift around with her movements, and we don't even need to see the vorgy to know how hot it is inside Beth!
The depth of the stories from the tinies continues to amaze me. You've put so much thought into each of these characters, a lot of them not getting a ton of "screen time" aside from their scene before being eaten. The level of detail you've put into each and every character is not unappreciated.
My impression of Amaterasu is that she doesn't think too highly of tinies. The way she teased Beth about being a tiny herself certainly implies that she looks down on them in a nonliteral way as much as a literal one. While the main reason the sun goddess gives for this is Beth devoting so much attention to her feet, her first two cited reasons are a bit demeaning for tinies. Amaterasu seems to take slight issue with Beth both dating a tiny and allowing the 12 other tinies to enjoy a literal orgy of sexual pleasure first (and afterward, theoretically) instead of merely eating them. It seems as though Beth's plate for the evening feels as though tinies aren't worth the time that Beth is putting into this.
That's something that I think contrasts really, really well with Beth's approach, especially in this chapter. Beth is immensely enjoying being a predator, but at the same time, she's acknowledging the humanity of her prey. At first I thought that was just for manipulative purposes, but over the course of the story so far (and especially in this chapter), it seems clear to me that there's something more going on here.
Beth wants to know these girls' names and their stories. She wants to remember them. True to the symbolism vore represents, it seems as though she truly wants them to become a part of her, not just in body, but in mind and soul as well. I think this is most clearly demonstrated in her reaction to Dulce's story. She feels bad for the itty bitty Italian for moving halfway across the world just to experience the same fate she was fleeing (which is really fucking sad, by the way).
Beth seems moved by this and wants to make sure Dulce isn't the one Amaterasu chooses as her payment. Beth wants it to be her that does in the tiny woman. This isn't because of some perverse pleasure she hopes to feel about the irony of the situation. Unlike Dulce's concerns about Cecilia, Beth wants the little woman to choose to be eaten by her, to accept it and want it. In fact, Beth seems determined to win over someone she could simply take between her fingers and stuff in her mouth. Why is that? While we're at it, why would someone like Beth, who is madly in love with a tiny herself, even entertain an evening such as this in the first place?
Between the stories told by Beth's meal, what we know of Cassidy's own story, and Amaterasu's actions thus far, it seems like tinies have it pretty rough. This society seems to pretend to care about them, but it's a poorly kept secret that the life of a tiny is meant to be just a thing for a big to enjoy however they see fit. So I think Beth is indulging a deep, dark desire, here, but I also think she sees these tinies she's eating as fucked either way. Why not give them a the time of their lives before they succumb to their inevitable fate. Add into account that Cassidy herself has asked to be eaten before, and this doesn't even seem that far-fetched an idea for Beth to have.
Back to evidence about Beth's motivation, Cassia seems to be another prime example. Upon hearing the Greek's tragic story of running away from religious zealots intending to do the same thing to her that Beth herself is doing (although the sex part seems much more big-oriented than it is here), Beth is momentarily loses her drive to go through with this, only gaining it back when she realizes that the tiny only ran because she didn't want to die via a sexed up and probably hungry elderly nun (I mean, haven't we all been there?). Beth was even perceptive enough to pick up on Cassia wanting to be talked down to and obliging her, which was really touching even despite the cruelness such words and actions would normally carry.
And, of course, Beth wouldn't eat her without knowing her name. It's so much harder to remember someone when you don't know their name.
So yeah, despite consuming them, I think Beth's opinion of tinies is much higher than the average persons and that these manipulative games that she's been playing throughout the night are a sign of respect for her prey rather than simply something she's doing for her own enjoyment (although, that's most certainly a thing, too!). The fact that envisioning the vorgy inside her and finding joy in doing imagining the girls enjoying their final hours on Earth seems to back this idea up as well.
Beth's perspective may be a bit twisted, thinking that she's giving the tinies one last hoorah before they suffer an unavoidable fate anyway when she's the one acting as their executioner, but I get it. Some of the tinies do, too, as most of them seem to come to terms with it and just try to enjoy the opportunity presented to them. That's pretty telling, too. I was worried that the story was going to get a tad less interesting once Beth revealed her intentions to the remaining tinies, but my intrigue has been ramped up quite a bit since then, and I feel like my understanding of the situation has increased significantly!
The Alice in Wonderland stuff with Alice was great, by the way! The way you kept referring to that "Cheshire grin" was pretty slick, and there was a moment when Beth bent over the tiny and talked to her from behind that made me think of that particular cat's movements. Beth's playful references were so much fun! This was a phenomenal scene!
It also seems as though Beth is starting to feel as though Cassidy might be in danger. Her reluctance to put her tiny lover in Amaterasu's mouth even at Cassidy's own prompting shows an uneasiness building in the back of her mind, although her instruction to the sun goddess made my heart melt! I also feel like Beth putting Cassidy inside her before asking Amaterasu about her choice was a subconscious way of trying to protect her tiny girlfriend. I've fallen in love with their relationship in such a short amount of time (and even without a ton of interaction between them), which makes my all the more concerned about Cassidy's fate.
Speaking of that, I loved the way you played around with Valerie and the VIP wristband. I think the wristband has always been a red herring meant to distract us from a much greater danger, but having Beth observe this and keeping a close eye on the situation even during her orgasmic bliss again shows how much she cares for Cassidy. I thought noting that Cassidy rubbing her wrist wasn't normal and that she was playing with her wristband in a moment of guilt was a nice touch, and it helped hit home why Beth was suddenly very eager to get Valerie down her throat and out of the way. That interest in Val's story seemed to go away as soon as Beth saw Cassidy considering something stupid.
Man, Amaterasu sure did want Beth to gobble down another tiny really quickly. I'm guessing her count on tinies remaining doesn't quite match Beth's ...
Yeah, it might be time to panic about Cassidy.
Then again, you mention this "additional coda" that would show Cassidy's life weeks after the story, which very strongly indicates her survival. No mention of Beth, though. Again, much like the foreshadowing tag, I find myself wondering about the true intent of this announcement. Either you're extremely clever or I'm extremely paranoid. Or this could be a classic "both" scenario.
In any case, you've got me running circles around in my own head over this! So thanks for that (I mean this both literally and sarcastically at the same time, if that's possible)!
Oh, and that's wonderful news on Small Investments! I assumed you were going to come back to it at some point, but it's great to see confirmation! Take your time rereading and immersing yourself back into the story. You might enjoy the ride as a reader almost as much as you did writing it!
Author's Response:
I'm literally blown away. At 1,840 words, I'm pretty sure you doubled the median chapter length on the site. From the depths of my being, THANK YOU for this review.
I might have mentioned this previously, but I started this story when I had an entire afternoon free to write. My first instinct was to work on Small Investments, but I had taken so long in writing it that I wanted to do a full re-read of the previous chapters to make sure I maintained continuity, and didn't overlook small but crucial details. I have a list of 13 story ideas I intend to write some day, but they're longer form, so I decided to write a truly short story. I'd had this vague idea for a Mixed-sized couple where the big was a voraphile, and the tiny was a bit of a nympho who could look past her partner's dangerous tastes if she got in on the action before her lover got her lips on the tinies. I wanted to keep it compact, so it would be a meal, and then I decided to throw in the idea of Nyotaimori to make the whole thing an exotic, sizey twist on a taboo. I figured it would be a quick grab and gobble, and it would shake off the rust on my fingers. That was like half an hour of my writing session gone to brainstorming, and by the time the afternoon was done and I had a couple thousand words on the page, I knew there was so much more potential to this story than I could extract in one sitting. And so, on my long commutes to and from work, I brainstormed ideas for this story, a story that was fresh and new, and therefore completely malleable because I hadn't established anything yet to an audience. I'm very much of the opinion that an act is so much more meaningful if it is personal, if you understand what the consequences will be for both parties, and even moreso if you're invested in both parties. And so, I decided to flesh out the backstories of the tinies, revealing them as our MC ate her way through them. And with ample hours of commute time, it grew from there.
When it comes to word choice, it's very much a matter of getting the chapter written, and then going back through, start to finish. If anything feels off (based on a couple decades of reading experience) I start rewriting paragraph by paragraph with a thesaurus handy.
As for the society of this world, the sense you're getting fits the concept I had in mind. I'm glad that is being communicated properly.
Thanks for all the feedback on how I've portrayed Beth, Amaterasu, and the tinies, as well as your sense of their intentions, goals, and likely next steps. It seems everything I intended to communicate is sensible and understandable, and I didn't seriously mess up anywhere. My intentional points of ambiguity don't seem to be causing any trouble. This is great to hear!
The one thing I want to clarify about the coda (which is totally going to be written, I can't tease it and not complete it) is that I did say it would take place a couple months after the fallout of this story. I neither see nor recall mentioning Cassidy, or any other character by name. (If I did, it was totally an accident, so we should ignore it and pretend it isn't there)
And yes, Small Investments is definitely next on my To Write list. A full re-read, then finishing the story, and then I'm going to take a break from size writing for a while. Years ago I started a fantasy series I plan to eventually publish under a different pen name, but I had some issues with my MC coming across as boring, vanilla, unsatisfying, and frankly without a meaningful character flaw. Working on my character writing was a large part of what pushed me into size writing. Anyway, I'm going to take some time to get that story edited and ready for my beta readers (read college friends and one VERY [Seriously, VERY] persistent co-worker), and then I'll be back. I have quite a few story ideas in the tank, I'll probably pick my top 5, and write a chapter 1 for each, and see how they feel. Maybe I'll post them and let folks on the Discord chime in, see what they're interested in. That will probably be sometime next summer.
Anyway, this response has digressed far enough, likely due to my shock at this incredible review. Thank you so much for both being a reader, and for providing so much incredible feedback. I hope my writing continues to be worthy of the time you have invested in it.
Date: October 15 2024 4:06 AM Title: Chapter 5 - Tiny Sampler Platter for Two
Just finally got around to reading this one. Wonderful story so far, an absolute delight. I'm really looking forward to seeing the remainder of it. I have a prediction on something I'm curious to see if happens. Thank you for the really unique and well written tale
Author's Response:
Thanks for leaving a review, and I'm so glad to hear you're enjoying the story!
Ooh, I'm curious to hear what you think is going to happen! Feel free to send me a DM on Discord with your theory, you can find me there under the pen name I use here.
Chapter 6 was just posted, I hope you continue to find it to your liking.